There’s been a lot of news lately about Google+ and the removal of certain profiles from the network. Before the rumor mill gets out of hand, we wanted to confirm or dispel some of the myths we’ve heard, so you have the right knowledge handy for managing your own Google+ profile, if you have one…
Myth #1: Google+ is removing fake profiles (and also some not-so-fake ones)
Reality: TRUE.
Google+ made it clear early on that fake profiles wouldn’t be allowed to last. The policy of using real names (or at least the names people most often go by) has been in place since the network’s launch, and users were encouraged to set up their profiles under whatever name they most commonly use in order to “fight spam and prevent fake profiles” (from their User Content and Conduct Policy).
Sure enough, the powers that be started culling the Google+ population of anything that seemed fake as of a week or so ago. Some users found their accounts suspended, and unfortunately, not all of those users were using fake names. Mashable reports that Limor “Ladyada” Fried and lifestyle blogger A.V. Flox were among those who were deactivated, although they at least had the pull to get their profiles reinstated quickly. For some others who had distinctive names, though, the shutdown was a frustrating and unwarranted penalty.
Google has responded to the outcry over their heavy-handed attempts to administer justice to fake profiles, and they promise to do better. For now, Google says that they’ll issue warnings to users that they suspect have fake profiles, giving the users a chance to fix the situation before a suspension is issued. And they claim that they’re working on better ways for the Google+ system to handle alternate names like maiden names and pseudonyms. It remains to be seen whether these changes make the network a bit less rigid in its profile policing.
For those who have already been suspended, there is slim hope. First, you can request a review during the sign-up process, and you can fill out the form with links to other websites that will prove you are who you say you are (or you can submit a photo ID). If this appeal works, your account will come back up within 24 hours. Don’t expect an email notice or anything like that – your account will simply be un-suspended when you go back to it.
If the first appeal doesn’t work, you’ll have to make a second appeal, which starts when you go to your Google+ profile page and click the appeal link. Use the form to tell Google everything you can that might help prove you are who you say you are. Keep in mind that, if this step doesn’t work, your profile might be shut down for good.
Next, you simply wait. There’s no 24-hour turnaround on this step of the process, so you must be patient and wait for Google to get back to you. Some people report waiting for days to get their accounts reinstated, and other people are STILL waiting. You can try to speed up the process by having friends on Google+ contact some Google+ Community Managers for you via their profile pages (there’s a list of them here at the g+ Insider’s Guide), or you can go into a forum like the Google+ Help Forum to post about your difficulties and receive help from others in the forum.
Again, you won’t receive any notification that your profile is active again… It’ll simply be un-suspended. You’ll have to check back with it to be sure.
Right now, the Google+ profile section of the help forum is flooded with people who are confused, angry and frustrated at their profile suspensions. Many of them are using nicknames or other “names they most commonly use in everyday life” but that don’t appear on a government-issued ID, and while Google states that it wants people to use their most common names for their profiles, they seem to REALLY want legal names, since they ask for proof of identity via ID as part of the appeals process. Many people have upstanding, long-term online identities by which they are commonly known, and some of those people are protesting what a “name” really is for the purposes of social media and community. It will be interesting to see whether Google can get its act together regarding what constitutes a name and an identity on their network.
Myth #2: If your Google+ profile is suspended, then you won’t be able to access your Gmail, Google Docs or other Google accounts, either.
Reality: FALSE, at least at the moment.
There have been some reports that a suspended Google+ profile means that any other Google accounts linked to that profile are also shut down. Fleep Tuque went through this problem and posted a description of what happened and how she got her accounts reopened (for her Gmail, she had to confirm her phone number to get access reinstated). It sounds like she’s not the only one dealing with this “shut down everything” phenomenon.
In response to the stories that were spreading like wildfire across the web, Google came out last week with a statement saying that a suspended Google+ account will NOT mean a suspension of the user’s other accounts in Google. Whether you wish to put your faith in Google on this or not, it does seem like they’re trying to minimize the hassle of a profile suspension and how it affects other aspects of Google. There might have been a link between the various accounts a few weeks ago (causing the havoc that some users experienced), but for now, Google insists that Gmail, Google Docs and other Google services won’t suffer because of a Google+ account suspension. If you have an experience that says otherwise, please post in the comments here and let us know. We’d definitely want to call Google out on this if it’s a persistent problem and not just some early glitches that have since been fixed.
One thing to note, though: From what we can tell, if someone under 13 tries to set up a Google+ account (and answers the age question honestly), they WILL suffer a suspension of all of their linked accounts, not just the Google+ profile. Google is setting up a hard line regarding children on social networks, and they won’t permit kids to use their service. We think it’s fine to keep kids off of social networks until they reach an appropriate age, but many kids also use Gmail and other Google services (my own kids email with their grandparents and out-of-state friends via Gmail accounts). The bottom line is this: Parents, do NOT let your kids set up Google+ accounts if they’re under 13, especially if they use other Google services that they wish to continue using. It’s for their own good AND for the good of complying with Google’s rules.
Myth: Google+ is requiring private profiles to go public.
Reality: TRUE.
Having a Google+ profile means having a Google profile, which many people already have (note: a Google profile isn’t a requirement for Gmail, the calendar, Google Docs or some of the other features). Some people have private Google profiles, meaning that the contents aren’t visible in a public search. But now, those people have been notified that they either need to go public or delete their accounts. Google set a deadline of July 31 for this, which has now passed; anyone with a private profile that’s still set to private will probably see it removed shortly.
Why force public access? We suppose that Google wants Google+ to be a social network of sharing, not secrets. And there’s also the fact that Google makes its money on selling space to advertisers (making “user eyeballs” the product being sold), and people who lock up their profiles and hide all their info are useless to Google. Most profiles on there are already public, and on the bright side, users can set their profiles to show nothing more than their names if they so choose, while still maintaining that public, searchable aspect (this means that their profile could be found if someone was looking, but that someone couldn’t see more than the user’s name).
If you have a private profile, you’ll get a choice: “display my full name publicly” or delete the profile. If you wish to keep your profile, choose the public display option but then go into your profile and remove the visibility of whatever you don’t want to share (except your name – no choice on that one). If you want to make sure that you’ve locked down your profile correctly, go to the top right of your Google+ profile page and click the box that says “see how your profile appears to others.” You can choose to view your own profile as any stranger on the web would view it, thereby ensuring that you’re not oversharing in your profile.
Google+ is clearly having some growing pains, but it will be interesting to watch how it evolves and adapts to handle the feedback that users are giving it. Whether it will challenge Facebook at all is still unknown, but at the very least, it’s a novelty that’s getting a lot of attention, good AND bad. We’ll keep your apprised as privacy issues arise!